Griddle vs Grill: Which Belongs in Your Outdoor Kitchen?
Posted by The BBQ Authority Team on Nov 20th 2026
A grill cooks over open grates, so heat and flame reach the food directly, which is ideal for searing steaks, getting char marks and adding smoky flavor. A griddle cooks on a solid, flat steel surface, which is better for foods that would fall through or stick to grates: eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, fried rice, chopped vegetables and seafood. Most outdoor cooks don't need to choose. A griddle works best alongside a grill, as a built-in flat top, a freestanding griddle or an insert for the grill you already have.
Picture a Saturday morning on the patio. Bacon is crackling at one end of a wide steel flat top, pancakes are bubbling in the middle, and a pile of hash browns is getting crispy at the other end. Everyone's out there with coffee, and nobody had to stand at the stove inside.
Then picture that same evening: thick ribeyes on the grill, flames licking up through the grates, and that unmistakable char you can only get over fire. Both scenes are outdoor cooking at its best, and they need different tools.
Griddle vs Grill: How They Cook Differently
A grill heats food through open grates. Some heat comes from the flame and hot air, and some comes from the grates themselves. Drippings fall onto heat shields or burners and turn into smoke, which adds flavor.
A griddle heats a solid sheet of steel. Food sits directly on that hot surface, so it browns evenly across its entire bottom. Nothing falls through, and fats and oils stay on the surface to help with cooking.
What Each One Does Best
| Food | Better on a grill | Better on a griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Steaks and chops | ✓ | |
| Burgers | Classic grilled burgers | Smash burgers with crispy edges |
| Chicken | Bone-in pieces and thighs | Chopped chicken for fajitas or stir-fry |
| Breakfast | ✓ Eggs, bacon, pancakes, hash browns | |
| Seafood | Whole fish, thick fillets, kebabs | Shrimp, scallops, delicate fillets |
| Vegetables | Corn, peppers, thick slices | Diced veggies, onions, mushrooms |
| Rice and noodles | ✓ Fried rice, hibachi, stir-fry | |
| Sandwiches | Grilled bread | Cheesesteaks, quesadillas, grilled cheese |
Benefits of an Outdoor Griddle
Versatility. A flat top cooks foods your grill simply can't handle, opening up breakfast, hibachi nights and diner-style favorites.
Cooking for a crowd. A large griddle can cook dozens of pieces of bacon or a mountain of fajita fillings at once.
Zones. Many griddles have multiple burners, so you can keep one side hot for searing and the other side low for warming.
Fewer flare-ups. With no open grates, grease doesn't drip onto flames.
Where a Grill Still Wins
Char and smoke. A griddle can brown food beautifully, but it can't give you grill marks or the smoky flavor of drippings hitting the heat.
Thick cuts. Thick steaks, bone-in chicken and roasts benefit from a closed lid and grill heat around the food.
Rotisserie and indirect cooking. Many premium grills offer rotisseries, rear burners and the ability to cook indirectly, which a griddle can't do.
That's why most outdoor cooks who add a griddle keep their grill too.
Three Ways to Add a Griddle
1. A built-in griddle
A built-in griddle is the classic outdoor kitchen griddle. It drops into your island next to the grill, just like a side burner. It's the cleanest look and gives you a dedicated flat top that's always ready. Like any built-in, it has its own cutout dimensions, so plan for it when designing the island. Our guide to built-in grill cutout dimensions explains how to measure.
2. A freestanding griddle
A freestanding griddle comes on its own cart, so you can add it to a patio without building anything. It's a great option if you already have a grill you love, or if you're not ready for a full outdoor kitchen.
3. A griddle insert for your grill
The easiest and most affordable option is a griddle insert that sits on your existing grill grates. It's a great way to try griddle cooking before committing to a dedicated flat top, though a full griddle offers more space and more even heat.
Brands Worth Knowing
- Le Griddle: Thick, heavy-duty griddles with multiple heat zones, available as built-in, freestanding and countertop units.
- Evo: Distinctive round flat tops that let several cooks work around the surface at once, popular for entertaining.
- Napoleon: The Phantom Rogue PRO 30" Rust-Resistant Gas Griddle is a stand-alone griddle on its own cart, with a 480 sq. in. stainless steel cooktop, four burners, folding side shelves and a front-access grease tray. It's a great fit if you want a dedicated flat top without building it into an island.
- Grill brands: Many outdoor kitchen brands, including Blaze and Coyote, make griddles designed to match their grills and islands.
Steel Matters: Seasoning and Care
Griddle cooking surfaces are usually made from either carbon steel or stainless steel, and they're cared for differently.
- Carbon steel builds a natural nonstick layer, called seasoning, over time. It needs to be kept oiled to prevent rust, especially outdoors.
- Stainless steel is more resistant to rust and doesn't need the same seasoning routine, though food can stick more until you learn how to manage heat and oil.
Whichever you choose, clean the surface while it's still warm with a scraper, wipe it down, and add a light coat of oil if your manufacturer recommends it. Use a good cover between cooks. Our grill maintenance schedule covers cleaning habits that apply to griddles too.
So, Do You Need a Griddle?
In the griddle vs grill debate, the honest answer is that most families end up wanting both. You'll probably love a flat top grill if:
- You want to cook breakfast outside
- Your family loves smash burgers, cheesesteaks, fajitas or hibachi-style meals
- You often cook for a crowd
- You already have a grill and want to expand what you can cook
You may not need one if you mostly grill steaks, chicken and vegetables a few times a month, or if counter space in your island is tight. In that case, start with a griddle insert and see how often you use it.
If you're planning a new outdoor kitchen, our 10 outdoor kitchen layout mistakes to avoid guide can help you make room for both. BBQ Authority is the one-stop shop for grills, pizza ovens, outdoor kitchens, and accessories, so your grill, griddle and island components can come from one order.
Top Griddle Picks
Built-in, freestanding and countertop griddles for every outdoor kitchen.
2. Napoleon Phantom Rogue PRO 30" Rust-Resistant Gas Griddle
A stand-alone griddle with a rust-resistant stainless cooktop, four burners and a 15-year warranty.
3. Le Griddle
Heavy-duty flat tops with multiple heat zones.
4. Evo
Round flat tops built for entertaining.
5. BBQ Griddles
Griddle inserts to try flat-top cooking on the grill you already have.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a griddle and a grill?
A grill cooks over open grates for char and smoky flavor. A griddle cooks on a solid steel surface, which is better for eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, fried rice and small or delicate foods.
Can a griddle replace a grill?
For some foods, yes, but not completely. A griddle can't create grill marks, smoky flavor or indirect heat for thick cuts, so most outdoor cooks use both.
Is a built-in griddle worth it?
If you cook breakfast, smash burgers or hibachi-style meals often, a built-in griddle adds a lot of versatility. If you're unsure, start with a griddle insert.
Can I put a griddle on my gas grill?
Yes. Griddle inserts sit on top of your grill grates and are an easy way to try flat-top cooking.
How do you clean an outdoor griddle?
Scrape it while warm, wipe it down and apply a thin coat of oil if your manufacturer recommends it. Keep it covered between cooks.
Make Room for the Flat Top
A griddle doesn't replace your grill. It gives your outdoor kitchen a whole new menu. If you're deciding between a built-in, freestanding or insert griddle, BBQ Authority offers expert customer service to help you choose, with live chat, phone and email support. Shop griddles and outdoor kitchen components at bbq-authority.com or call 866-238-9228, and get ready for the best breakfast your backyard has ever smelled.